| Rank | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 | 2023 | 2024 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Pin Pop | Jelly Tots | Jelly Tots | Pin Pop | Pin Pop | Pin Pop | Maynards | Maynards | Maynards | Maynards |
| 2 | Jelly Tots | Astros | Pin Pop | Jelly Tots | Jelly Tots | Jelly Tots | Pin Pop | Cadbury Eclairs | Cadbury Eclairs | Jelly Tots |
| 3 | Astros | Pin Pop | Maynards Wine Gums | Smarties | Smarties | Smarties | Smarties | Amajoya | Yogueta | Amajoya |
| 4 | Jelly Belly Beans | Smarties | Smarties | Mentos | Maynards Jelly Babies | Mentos | Jelly Tots | Yogueta | Pin Pop | M&M's |
| 5 | Smarties | Fizzer | Maynards Jelly Babies | Fizzer | Mentos | Smoothies | Yogueta | Jelly Tots | M&Ms | Yogueta |
| 6 | Maynards Wine Gums | Jelly Belly Jelly Beans | · | · | Fizzer | · | · | Smoothies | Beacon Sweets | Pin Pop |
| 7 | Yogueta | Smoothies | · | · | Maynards Wine Gums | · | · | Pin Pop | Manhattan Marshmallows | Cadbury Eclairs |
| 8 | Maynards Jelly Beans | Yogueta | · | · | Smoothies | · | · | Halls | Skittles | Skittles |
| 9 | Maynards Jelly Babies | Mentos | · | · | Yogueta | · | · | Pengo | Amaiova | Big Bomb |
| 10 | Manhattan Sour Worms | Chappies | · | · | Cadbury Eclairs | · | · | Stumbo | Stumbo | Beacon Sweets |
#1
Gold
- 2015 Pin Pop
- 2016 Jelly Tots
- 2017 Jelly Tots
- 2018 Pin Pop
- 2019 Pin Pop
- 2020 Pin Pop
- 2021 Maynards
- 2022 Maynards
- 2023 Maynards
- 2024 Maynards
#2
Silver
- 2015 Jelly Tots
- 2016 Astros
- 2017 Pin Pop
- 2018 Jelly Tots
- 2019 Jelly Tots
- 2020 Jelly Tots
- 2021 Pin Pop
- 2022 Cadbury Eclairs
- 2023 Cadbury Eclairs
- 2024 Jelly Tots